INTERNATIONAL MEETING, 4,5,6 and 7th March 1999,
Barcelona
Pompeu Fabra University, C/ Ramón
Trias Fargas 25
‘Food and agriculture in North-South Relations’
Context: The free market in foodstuffs in claimed to be the best solution to world hunger. According to this dogma, the elimination of trade barriers allows all countries to profit from their comparative advantatges, which in turn benefits local communities because in this way, we are assured, they will be able to buy imported foodstuffs at lower prices.
After the Uruguay round, while the
countries of the South have been obliged to remove subsidies for
agricultural productions, subsidies for farmers in the northern countries
have been strengthened.
Far from eradicating hunger, trade
liberalisation is worsesning the problem of insecurity of food supply by
forcing the South’s producers to compete, at a disadvantage, eith
subsidised agricultural systems od the capital/intensive North.
At the same time, trade liberalisation is spreading the exploitation of the Earth’s biodiversity, encouraging the processes leading to a concentration of land ownership, increasing the rural worker’s dependence on transnational corporations and promoting these corporations’monopolisaation of genetic and agricultural resources.
The international meeting “Food and
Agriculture in South-North Relations” is part of the
informative project “Natural Resources, Biodiversity and Interdepencencein
South-North Relations”. This is a programme of information, education and
raising public awareness. It has the following aims:
? create public awareness of the
social and environmental repercussions of this model of development
in the food and agricultural sector
? help those persons and groups
working against the inequality and injustice caused by this econonmic model,
by giving them the chance to express their views
PROGRAMME
Block 1
- Trade Globalisation: Impact on
food production and trade flows between South and North.
First Session: Thursday Evening
Discussion:
- Trade Globalisation: The
role of the multinationals and development agencies. The role of other
development actors (development agencies, developmental NGOs, financial
institutions, governments). Social and economic consequences.
Contents:
- WIDE.- A feminist critique
of the Neo-liberal, market oriented, view of the economy; Alternatives
to Neo-liberalism; Gender and Environment (Agriculture)
- Speaker from the South. The agricultural
model in countries of the South. Disadvantages fro trade, with globalisation.
- Bob Sutcliffe (HEGOA). (Department
of Applied Economics, University of Bilbao) Economic globalization and
the ‘development machine’. The role NGOs, financial institutions
and of the multinationals.
- Henk Hobbelink (GRAIN). The privatisation
of biodiversity and knowledge of biodiversity. The importance of the traditional
system of innovation. The role of the multinationals in the development
model.
Moderator: Mbuyi Kabunda (SODePAZ)*
* It is important to note that the role of the Moderator is not only to introduce the participants, but also to make a summary of all of the contributions which will be incorporated into his own presentation, at the end.
Block 2
? Impact of the agricultural model
on different social sectors and on natural resources
Second Session: Friday evening
Discussion
Topics to be discussed:
a) Natural Resources
- Soil erosion and desertification
processes.
- Over-use of water resources in
monocultures and irrigated crops, especially in arid and semi-arid zones.
- Reduction of biodiversity and
the monopolisation of seed varieties
- Monocultures, pests and pesticides-
a vicious circle. Effects on health and environment.
- Exportation of non-adapted and
obsolete technology from North to South.
b) Social sectors
- Rural workers: trade unions and
farming cooperatives (land reform)
- Indigenous movements and cultural
diversity
- Women and agriculture
- Consumers in
the North
Helen Groome (EHNE, union of Basque
farmers): Sovereignty of foodstuffs and repercussions for the environment
Montse Peiron (CEIC, Centre for
Resources and Research regarding Consumption ) The impact on consumers
of the agricultural model.
Palestinian Hydrology Group (PHG):
Geo-ppolitics of water resources in the Mediterranean.
Moderator: Isabel Bermejo (AEDENAT)
Third session: Saturday 6th, all day
Block 3
? Practical experience: proposals
and alternatives to the existing model.
Morning: Three simultaneous conferences, with speakers in groups of two (discussion in small groups)
a) Agricultural cases
- Organic farming in Cuba (ANAP)
- The struggle for land ownership.
The social movement of the M.S.T. (landless workers) in Brazil
- The use of water resources in
Palestine (PHG)
- Communal and sustanaible forest
mangement in Ecuador. (OPIP)
- Project of recovery of varieties
of rice. Encouraging biodiversity and the struggle for land (MASIPAG, Phillipine
Islands)
- Alternative proposals for conserving
genetic resources (Farida Akhter, Bangladesh)
- Rural settlements and agro-ecology
in Andalusia. (Eduardo Sevilla Guzman. Instituto Sociológico de
Estudios Campesinos)
- The importance of family
farming. Responses to the agricultural policies of the European Union (the
CAP). Pilar Galindo (Coordinator of farming and livestock organisations).
b) Experiences of commercialisation:
- Cooperativer of Fair Trade products,
MCCH (Ecuador) or CEIBO (Bolivia)
- Relations between public restaurants
and native produce sectors in Peru. (TMB). Miriam Bustamante
- Cooperative of local consumers
in the North. GERMINAL
- Regional market project in North
Africa, not based on free-market liberalism. Fatiha Talahite
Chaired debate:
? Fair trade: Is it a tool or an
alternative for mobilising movements critical of the unequal situation
of interdependence north- South?
Participants: Xavier Montagut (SODEPAU),
Osvaldo (Equimercado), Rafael Sanchez (INTERMON), Fundació Pau i
Solidaritat
Moderator: Rafael Grasa, President,
Catalan Federation of NGDOs.
Block 4
? New technologies in food and agriculture.
Lack of transparency, monopolisation and possible dangers of transgenic
foodstuffs.
Fifth session: Sunday morning
Discussion
- Paco Fernandez Buey (Pompeu Fabra
University). Epistemological critique of biotechnology. The subordination
of science to the political and economic powers.
- Isabel Bermejo (AEDENAT) Social
and environmental consequences of genetic manipulation.
- Memeber of GRAIN: The need
for another research paradigm. From genetic reductionism to systematic
thought.
- Verena Stolcke (Anthropologist,
Barcelona Autonomous University) Gender and technological research.
Moderator: Gregorio Alvaro Campos
(AEDENAT)
CONCLUSIONS AND CLOSE OF MEETING
J.M. Navarro